Just to cut things short. I have been wondering all this while, which market generates higher returns. FKLI or CPO ?
As a futures trader, I am concerned about risk vs reward. Risk vs reward comes from something called " volatility " and volatility can be the best friend or the worst enemy of a trader. I embrace volatility but then, I am quite cautious when it comes to volatility.
Let's look into the history of FKLI .
FKLI is considered to be safe market.. index futures are generally safer than commodity futures because volatility is lower. FKLI was born in the year 1995 or 1996 and if we were to look at the crash of year 1997 and 1998, it offered one of the greatest opportunities ever in the futures market. At that time, I am not sure how much the margin is but money per point was RM100 instead of RM50 as of current.The rebound from 1998 to 1999 was a great opportunity as well.
Eventually in around 2002-2005, FKLI became more and more quiet and as we have seen in year 2005,the market was moving sideways. That was the time, the margin requirement was about RM 1200 and money per point was RM 50. In year 2006, we witnessed a great bull market followed by the great volatile market in year 2007.
Let's talk about recent movements. In year 2011 and 2012, the market was quite steady and offered great opportunity for futures trader whilst trading with reduced risk.
Let's now look into the history of FCPO.
Nothing much to talk about CPO . The market has changed ever since year 2007 when extreme volatility is seen. Year 2008 was a brutal market that has killed so many traders before the great crash starting from 3700 ( after the great rebound and sideways movement ). Ever since then, volatility remains high while money per point is at RM25. Margin requirement ranges from RM 6000 to RM 9000. At the highest,it has reached to RM 15000( slightly below,in year 2008 ).
Now , to summorize the whole thing . Volatility can be the best friend or the worst enemy of a trader. When volatility increases,risk increases and more capital is required for trading. I repeat, more capital is required for trading.
If we were to look at CPO from systematic trading point of view, we have to look at the potential largest drawdown due to the extreme volatility of the market. This market went from a low margin market of about RM1200 per lot up to about RM 7000 per lot. While FKLI is hovering around RM 5000 per lot. 1 point in CPO is about RM 25 and 1 point in FKLI is RM 50.
CPO costs about RM 50000 to deleverage. FKLI costs about RM 85000 to deleverage.Assuming if we were to hold long positions until the end of the market.
If we were to analyze FKLI and FCPO, FCPO definitely requires a capital of ranging from RM 15k to RM 25K per lot while FKLI requires a capital of about RM8K up to 15K per lot. But in FKLI,we get higher leverage at lower risk. Why lower risk? Because lower volatility.
Yes, in CPO we are able to make 1000 points in a year but how many years can we do so? How much capital do we need to make that particular 1000 points? How about the drawdowns that we are supposed to encounter?
In FKLI our drawdowns are greatly reduced while we are able to fully leverage trading in the futures market.
Honestly speaking, I have gained my trading confidence not by making money in the index futures but by making money in the commodity futures ( CPO ). It has proven that I have a successful method and good market sense.
I would love to conclude that with a successful system or ...a good trading skill...whichever u implement... FKLI will eventually yield a higher return compared to FCPO !